What's Wrong With The Detroit Tigers?

---

Detroit:

By Troy Geary

Geary Sports & Entertainment Network 

When the 2026 season began, expectations were high for the Detroit Tigers. Coming off a playoff appearance and led by one of the best pitching staffs in baseball, many believed the Tigers were ready to take another step forward and become a legitimate contender in the American League after a successful season in 2025 and advancing to the ALDS. They took the Seattle Mariners to a game five, that went 15 innings. Instead, through 66 games, Detroit finds itself at 27-39 and searching for answers. 

While there is no single reason for the Tigers' disappointing start, injuries have played a major role. Detroit has spent much of the season without several key contributors. Ace Tarik Skubal has missed significant time with a loose body in his left elbow. Reportedly he is expected back soon. Casey Mize has battled groin and adductor injuries, while veteran Justin Verlander has spent the majority of the season on the injured list. Framber Valdez who signed late in the offseason has struggled, including being suspended five games for throwing at Boston Red Sox shortstop Trevor Story on May 5th. Losing three important starters has forced the Tigers to rely heavily on their pitching depth and has disrupted the consistency that made the rotation one of the club's biggest strengths entering the season. The injuries have not been limited to the pitching staff. 

Javier Báez has missed considerable time with a high ankle sprain, Parker Meadows has been sidelined with an arm fracture, that happened April 9th vs the Twins in Minnesota. Trey Sweeney is out for the season with a shoulder injury, and Kerry Carpenter has also spent time on the injured list. Gleyber Torres missed a month because of an oblique strain. When multiple everyday players are unavailable at the same time, it becomes difficult for any lineup to establish rhythm and consistency.

The bullpen has also been impacted. Veteran closer Kenley Jansen is on the 15-day IL a groin injury, while Brant Hurter is on the 60-day IL with severe spine inflammation, and Burch Smith is currently on the 15-day IL due to right shoulder inflammation. The constant roster turnover has forced manager A.J. Hinch to adjust roles throughout the season.

The injuries alone do not explain a 27-39 record. The biggest issue has been an offense that has struggled to score consistently. Too often the Tigers have put runners on base only to leave them stranded. Detroit has struggled to come up with timely hits in key situations, and several close games have slipped away because the club could not capitalize on scoring opportunities. The lineup has also lacked depth at times. Opposing pitchers have been able to navigate through the batting order without facing any pressure. While several players have produced solid individual numbers, the Tigers have rarely had the entire lineup contributing at the same time.  The starting rotation, despite the injuries, has still shown glimpses of being one of the better groups in baseball. 

However, the lack of run support has left little room for error. Quality starts have frequently gone unrewarded, and a single mistake has often been enough to decide games. The bullpen has faced similar challenges. Relievers have routinely entered games with one-run deficits or narrow leads. Over the course of a long season, those situations can take a toll, and Detroit has seen several late-game opportunities slip away. 

Defensively, the Tigers have also struggled in key moments. While they remain capable of making outstanding plays, untimely errors and missed opportunities have extended innings and allowed opponents to take advantage.  Perhaps the most frustrating part of the season has been the Tigers' inability to build momentum. Whenever Detroit appears ready to turn things around, another losing streak follows. Winning streaks have been difficult to sustain, and consistency has been hard to find in every aspect of the game.

The 27-39 record is not the result of one issue. It has been a combination of injuries, inconsistent offense, pitching performances, bullpen struggles, and mistakes in critical situations. The good news for Tigers fans is that there is still time left in the season. Many of the players currently on the injured list are expected to return, and the talent that helped Detroit's success in previous seasons remains on the roster.

But time is becoming a factor.  If the Tigers hope to make a run at the playoffs in the second half of the season, they will need to get healthier, score more consistently, and begin playing the type of baseball many expected when the season began. 

For now, the Tigers continue searching for answers.  At 27-39, the question is no longer whether Detroit has talent. The question is whether the club can overcome its injuries and inconsistencies before the season slips completely away. 

Pittsburgh:

By Troy Geary 

Geary Sports & Entertainment Network

The noise starts early now at PNC Park. Long before the first pitch leaves Paul Skenes’ hand, fans rise from their seats with phones already recording. Radar guns flash behind home plate. Television broadcasts linger on warmup pitches that would once have looked computer-generated. Every fifth day in Pittsburgh has begun to feel less like a regular-season baseball game and more like an event, so I had to experience it in person.

That alone marks a dramatic shift for the Pirates. For years, Pittsburgh baseball lived inside baseball’s middle ground, rebuilding, resetting, developing, waiting. The organization produced good players, occasionally exciting teams, but rarely the kind of transcendent talent capable of changing the trajectory of an entire franchise.

 Skenes has changed that. Around him, an emerging wave of young talent has changed something even more important, belief. The Pirates are no longer selling distant potential. They are assembling one of baseball’s most intriguing young cores.  And for the first time in decades, the future in Pittsburgh feels dangerously close.

Skenes remains the center of everything. His dominance has already elevated him beyond prospect hype into something larger, a franchise identity. Opposing hitters speak about his fastball with a mixture of respect and resignation. Evaluators see the rare combination every organization covets but few ever find, ace-level stuff paired with ace-level composure.

But the Pirates’ optimism does not stop with one pitcher. Behind Skenes, Pittsburgh has quietly built one of baseball’s deepest pitching pipelines. Bubba Chandler has emerged as another potential frontline starter, combining explosive velocity with rapidly improving command. Jared Jones and Braxton Ashcraft have reinforced the idea that the Pirates are no longer merely collecting hard throwers, they are developing them. Across baseball, evaluators increasingly view Pittsburgh as an organization capable of manufacturing elite pitching internally. 

Then there is Konnor Griffin, the teenager many scouts believe could eventually become the face of the franchise. Griffin represents the modern superstar prototype: power, speed, athleticism, defensive versatility, and the type of ceiling that transforms rebuilds into contention windows. Some evaluators already place him among the best prospects of the past decade. 

For Pittsburgh, that matters enormously. The Pirates have spent years searching for foundational position-player star power. Griffin may finally provide it. His rise gives the organization something it has lacked throughout much of its rebuilding cycle: balance. Skenes can anchor a rotation, but Griffin has the potential to electrify an entire lineup.

The broader roster only deepens the intrigue. Oneil Cruz remains one of baseball’s most physically gifted players, capable of changing games with a single swing. Bryan Reynolds continues to provide stability amid the transition. Young contributors like Nick Gonzales, Endy Rodríguez, and Henry Davis offer additional layers to a roster increasingly shaped by internal development rather than temporary solutions.

And yet, optimism in Pittsburgh always arrives with caution. Pirates' fans have seen talented cores before. They understand the realities of small-market baseball, where contention windows can close as quickly as they open. The challenge is no longer acquiring talent. The challenge is sustaining it. 

Can ownership spend aggressively enough when the moment arrives? Can the organization keep stars long term? Can the Pirates capitalize before financial realities force difficult decisions? Those questions linger over every promising development.

That tension is what makes this moment fascinating.

Because the Pirates are no longer rebuilding in theory. They are approaching the dangerous phase where expectations become real.

For years, Pittsburgh searched for signs that the franchise was finally turning a corner. Now, every fifth day, the answer may already be standing on the mound, throwing 100 miles per hour.